Martin Family Wineries & Distilleries - Either Oar Wine, Whiskey, & Cheese Bar

Sit-down wine and whiskey bar in Hector pairing Seneca Lake pours with local cheeses

Best known for: Honey and fruit wines alongside grape wines and spirits

Either Oar Wine, Whiskey, & Cheese Bar in Hector, New York, is Martin Family Wineries & Distilleries’ sit-down alternative to the traditional Finger Lakes tasting room. At the former Penguin Bay Winery on Seneca Lake’s east side, the emphasis is on settling in with a flight and something to eat rather than moving through samples at a counter. The fishing-inspired identity takes its cue from co-owner George Martin’s love of the sport.

The wines range from Borrowed Lure LaCrescent and dry rosé to Lake Cabin Red and a 2024 Saperavi dessert wine. Wine-and-cheese flights offer dry or sweet selections, while a separate whiskey flight pairs four whiskeys with local cheeses. Guests can also select four wines, sample four staff-chosen mini cocktails, or build a six-cheese flight. That breadth makes Either Oar a useful stop for a group whose tastes don’t all run to wine; mocktails are available, too.

Indoor and outdoor seating, charcuterie spreads, and a pet-friendly policy make this a stop worth leaving time for. The bar sits at 6075 NY-414, and groups of 12 or more require reservations through the tasting room at 607-546-5115.

Location & Nearby Wineries

Hector, New York · 0.7 mi away
Vibrant tasting room with playful wine experiences
Best known for: Unique fruit wines and fun experiences
Hector, New York · 1.0 mi away
Biodynamic estate with scenic lake vistas and innovative practices
Best known for: Saperavi varietal wines and innovative winemaking
Hector, New York · 1.2 mi away
Historic farmstead with private tasting experiences
Best known for: Award-winning wines and ciders
Hector, New York · 1.4 mi away
Scenic lakeview tasting room with handcrafted estate wines
Best known for: Handcrafted wines from estate-grown grapes
Hector, New York · 1.6 mi away
Artisanal tasting room with curated wine flights
Best known for: Handcrafted wines from Seneca Lake
Hector, New York · 1.9 mi away
Historic vineyard with sustainable practices and inviting tasting room
Best known for: Exceptional Rieslings and unique blends
Hector, New York · 1.9 mi away
Casual tasting room with budget-friendly wines
Best known for: Affordable wines starting at $10
Hector, New York · 2.0 mi away
Lodi, New York · 2.2 mi away
Family-run vineyard with scenic views and sustainable practices
Best known for: Handcrafted dry red wines
Dundee, New York · 2.3 mi away
Charming family-friendly venue with unique fruit wine experiences
Best known for: Diverse fruit wines including grape, blueberry, and cherry